Subscribe to RSS feed

«

»

Jul
23

City v. Suburbs: Part One

My friend, Lisa, wrote a blog post about why she didn’t go to Taste of Chicago this year. It’s on the new blogger community, The Chicago Moms, right here.

Her primary reason — aside from the heat, mediocre food, crowds and pale, large people who feel compelled to spill, shirtless, over their jean shorts and into your personal space — is the worry over violence. She’s got a little guy and had visions of bad things happening.

Bad things happen. To everyone. But if I had to point to a fundamental difference between moms and dads, aside from the whole breast feeding thing, it’s this. Moms worry over random acts of violence that will, of course, happen to them. Dads admit that these things happen, but we’re confident that they will happen to someone else.

There comes a point where most parents start having what I like to call the,  ”Maybe-we-should-move-the-hell-out-of-the-city-before-we’re-shot-in-the-forehead” conversation. Lara and I are having that now, sporadically. We can have it all we want. Thanks to the titans of Wall Street, we’re not selling our house anytime soon.

But still, we have it, every now and again. The wife grew up in the suburbs. I grew up in the city. Guess who wants to stay and who wants to leave?

I can recognize some of the appeal. Not having to pay $85 for a city sticker so you can park in front of your own house. Fewer sirens. Backyards that are larger than a postcard.

But I like the city. I work in the city. And, with Jack so young, I don’t feel like losing two hours a day on the train, going to and from work. Maybe I’m being selfish and will sing a different tune when he’s about ready to go to school. But for now, I want to stay put.

I think the wife does, too. But if I said let’s go, I don’t think she’d put up much a fight. Even so, we have some pretty funny conversations about it.

Wife: The suburbs are so nice. (She’s driving us home from Palatine, where Jack swims on Saturdays.)

Me: Uh-huh.

Wife: Summers growing up were the best. Going swimming and then being out at night, catching lightning bugs.

Me: We had lighting bugs in the city.

Wife: No you didn’t. Maybe one little lonely one.

Me: No. We had actual lightning bugs. A whole bunch of them.

Wife: No you didn’t.

Me: What do you think we did? Run around and catch rats in pillow cases?

Wife: Exactly.

There’s rats in the suburbs. I’ve seen them. They’re just smaller and ride ponies on their way to golf lessons.

  • Trenaldi

    I still have mixed feelings about our move to the suburbs two years ago. For a few months, we wouldn't admit it to anyone…we'd say things like “oh, we're living right on the edge of the city” (we're in Park Ridge). It would be hard to go back to our condo in Ravenswood now though, especially with a toddler. I'd miss the big grocery stores, the easier traffic and the sense of neighborhood/community. Oh, and I grew up in the city too, so I can vouch for your lightening bug story.

  • http://twitter.com/alexgorbokon alexgorbokon

    The suburbs aren't all bad, you just need to pick a good one next to the highway. I honestly think that while I live in Skokie, I spend more time out and around the city than most city-dwellers..so you'll be able to come back :) And you know the commute issue, isn't really an issue since the advent of smart phones.

    Here are some things you may like about the suburbs: http://suburbancityditty.blogspot.com/2010/04/b...

    And of course, take everything with a grain of salt since I'm trying to close on a condo in the city next week!

  • TheChicagoMoms

    RT @AlanKercinik: On the blog: suburbs v. city. inspired in part by @hannemaniacs post on @thechicagomoms. http://www.alwaysjacked.com/2010/07/city...
    via Twitoaster

  • http://www.hormonecoloreddays.blogspot.com Kim/hormone-colored days

    Thanks for The Chicago Moms shout-out. I'm a managing editor there, as well as a friend of Lisa's. When you are in the position of paying roughly $20K for your little guy to go to kindergarten (or possibly even preschool), those suburban houses do start to seem a bit more attractive. Personally, I'm here for the parking.

  • http://twitter.com/chambanalaura Laura Bleill

    Your last line made me giggle in Starbucks. I grew up in the burbs and never lived in the city, but have a very close cousin who did, and we have had a similar discussion about a zillion times over the years.

  • http://www.alwaysjacked.com Alan Kercinik

    I tend to think mixed feelings are always bundled up with parenthood. I will be the first to admit, and I'm being horrible shallow and probably ill-informed by saying this, but there is part of me that equates “moving to the suburbs” with “getting old.” I know this is ridiculous, but I do feel that way. Your upsides are definitely part of the draw, especially the community bit.

  • http://www.alwaysjacked.com Alan Kercinik

    Ah, the reverse move. We will welcome you to the city with open arms. I'll even try to find a lightning bug as a welcoming present.

  • http://www.alwaysjacked.com Alan Kercinik

    So nice to meet you. That Lisa, she brings people together.

    Paying that kind of money so Jack can eat paste and shove crayons up his nose seems a little nuts to me. I smell a move in our future when schooling is more of a looming concern.

  • http://www.alwaysjacked.com Alan Kercinik

    My highest aspiration as a writer is to get people to laugh out loud.

    Thanks for reading. Keep it real down there in Shampoo-Banana.

  • Elke

    Great read Alan…but where you grow up (if I'm correct) was a bit like a suburb. My dream in my younger years was to live on the East Side. We always shopped at Jewel on 106th, library, etc. I love Chicago, love, love, it….but only certain parts. The Chicago I grew up in was dangerous and well, a horrible experience. I think Lincoln square is great place to grow up but I must agree the school thing will become an issue. I have strong feelings on the City versus suburb thing but my experience made me who I am…very cautious. I feel free in the suburbs, don't worry about someone pushing me off my bike to steal it, or hold a gun to my head (happened when I was 11). I've been in the suburbs 15 years…and wouldn't change a thing. You're a great read Alan…publish something! One of these days I'm going to meet you at some festival in Lincoln Square…Elke

  • http://www.alwaysjacked.com Alan Kercinik

    Thanks, Elke. The part of the city I grew up in definitely had some suburban-esque elements — easy street parking, less traffic — but still had an urban sensibility and an ease to get to the city. I can't believe that happened to you when you were 11. If the day ever came where it happened to anyone in my family, I imagine we'd be suburban bound in about five minutes.

    Anytime you're in the hood, give a shout. Would love to see you again.

blog comments powered by Disqus